legislation

Dog/Cat Breeder Bill

q & a

talking points

follow the vote

opposition

S.F. 1118/H.F. 1369

S.F. 705/H.F. 1098

H.F. 1635

mn legislators

committees

how bill becomes law

governance

animal law

minnesota laws

animal welfare act

local government

other states

federal laws

federal: PUPS

  legislation > minnesota laws

 

Minnesota has State laws, cited below, which deal with animal cruelty and welfare, consumer protection, sales tax and other issues pertaining to the treatment of animals — and the impact on animals, consumers and communities.

Some of these laws, however, are misinterpreted — or not used or properly enforced. Without the correct law, knowledge of the law or enforcement of existing laws, animals in Minnesota will continue to be neglected, abused and exploited.

Below lists a few Minnesota laws with links and brief explanations.

 

PREVENTION OF CRUELTY TO ANIMALS
Every state and the District of Columbia have animal anti-cruelty laws. In 2002, Minnesota enacted legislation which also made acts of cruelty to certain animals a felony.

The specific definition of ‘Torture; cruelty” is in Subdivision 3 of Chapter 343.20. It reads: “Torture” or “cruelty” means every act, omission, or neglect which causes or permits unnecessary or unjustifiable pain, suffering, or death.” 

The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Law, while critically important, does not set breeding standards or prevent inhumane dog and cat breeding. Anti-cruelty laws apply after the fact — after the animal cruelty has already occurred.

Dog and cat breeding legislation, if enacted by Minnesota legislators, would help prevent animal abuse before it occurs by giving the State of Minnesota the authority to license dog and cat breeders, conduct inspections of facilities, enforce humane standards, and impose civil and criminal penalties. 

Law: Minnesota Statutes 2006, Chapter 343
http://www.revisor.leg.state.mn.us/..

Supporting links:

 

MINNESOTA CONSUMER PROTECTION — General

Minnesota has consumer protection laws protecting people from being misled about a product (i.e., told information which is false or misleading in order to get the consumer to purchase the product). The law focuses on fraud, misrepresentation, and deceptive business practices.

As animals are legally defined as property and, when bought and sold, are considered transactions or merchandise, this law also applies to the selling of dogs and cats. For instance, if a consumer is led to believe an animal is healthy, makes the purchase and then discovers the animal is sick due to breeding or care conditions, this is deception. If the consumer also incurs veterinarian costs to try and treat the animal, this is further proof of deception (resulting in financial and emotional damage).

If you find you have been a victim of consumer fraud, file a complaint with the Minnesota Office of Attorney General and also tell your story to Animal Folks MN.

• Minnesota Stat. Sec. 325F.69 Unlawful Practices

"The act, use, or employment by any person of any fraud, false pretense, false promise, misrepresentation, misleading statement or deceptive practice, with the intent that others rely thereon in connection with the sale of any merchandise, whether or not any person has in fact been misled, deceived, or damaged thereby, is enjoinable as provided in section 325F.70."

 

 

PET LEMON LAW - Consumer Protection, Products, and Sales
The sale of dogs and cats is subject to consumer protection, known as the Pet Lemon Law. This law outlines consumer rights and the responsibilities of pet dealers (i.e., pet stores) when selling a dog or cat.

As with the Animal Anti-Cruelty Law, the Pet Lemon Law applies after the fact — after a ‘buyer’ gets home and finds they purchased a ‘poor quality, unhealthy’ pet.

Even with this law in place, there are numerous examples where people, unknowingly, have purchased unhealthy pets. Once a person has bonded with their new companion, many people have no desire to return "it" for a refund. Click on link below for details of the law and duedates for action. Further information: Pet Stores

Pet Lemon Law - MN Statute 325F.79 to 325F.792

Explanation per MN Board of Animal Health

 

 

BEST MANAGEMENT STANDARDS FOR CARE OF DOGS AND CATS
In 1994, the Minnesota Legislature ordered the Commissioner of Agriculture to establish best management standards for the care of dogs and cats by dealers, commercial breeders, and brokers. Some people have claimed that these standards are ‘good enough’ for breeders and should simply be enforced.

The problem is twofold:


1) These standards are often misinterpreted. The “order” appears in bold text but the actual details, defining the specifics of the order, appear in itallic and are “suggestions and recommendations” only. Commercial breeders are not required, by law, to follow the suggestions; so, many don’t. As with other statutes, the bolded orders use vague language which is interpreted. Examples: “Animals must be provided with adequate shelter…” (“Adequate” is subject to interpretation.) Or “Temperature, ventilation, and lighting must be adequate for the type, number, and condition of animals involved.” (“Adequate” is subject to interpretation.) Or “All animals must be provided adequate exercise.” (“Adequate” is subject to interpretation.) The sentences following this standard state: "All animals should be provided the opportunity for exercise at least twice per day. Space should be sufficient for the animals to exercise freely." Because these sentences are italized, they are suggestions only — not law which can be enforced.


2) Enforcement is not possible by the State of Minnesota if the State is not legally authorized to inspect facilities, enforce compliance and impose penalties. Without licensing of dog and cat breeders and authorization to collect fees, for example, revenues are not collected to pay for resources needed to enforce the standards. Also, without law, no State agency is designated as the ‘authority’ to implement the law. The infrastructure and governance must be in place for enforcement to occur.

Breeder legislation, if enacted by Minnesota legislators, could close this gap by requiring dog and cat breeders in Minnesota to be licensed, and authorizing a state agency, such as the Minnesota Board of Animal Health, to administer the orders.

• Commissioner's Order: Best Management Standards

 

 

MINNESOTA STATUTE 346: STRAY ANIMALS; COMPANION ANIMALS

In 346.58 "Dogs and Cats; Best Management Standards for Care By Dealers, Commercial Breeders, And Brokers," it states: "The commissioner of agriculture shall...shall issue an order containing best management standards of care for dogs and cats by dealers, commercial breeders, and brokers. The commission shall urge dealers, commercial breeders, and brokers to follow the standards issued in the order."

Not the word "urge" in the above sentence. That is the problem with this law. Reputable breeders will follow humane standards; inhumane breeders will not and do not. "Urging" a business to act humanely does not hold up in court.

Even if rules, regulations and standards are mandatory by law, they are useless if no State agency is authorized to implement and execute what the law has ordered.

NOTE: When reading laws, be aware of the use of language. In this statute, for instance, the following statements are made: “Dogs and cats must be provided with food of sufficient quantity and quality.” (The definition of ‘sufficient’ can vary.) Or “Confinement areas must be maintained at a temperature suitable for the animal involved.” (The definition of ‘suitable’ varies.) This law does state: “Exercise for 20 to 30 minutes and water must be provided at least once every eight hours;” however, per the law, this only applies to animals when they are being transported and shipped.

 

MINNESOTA STATUTE 347.31: MN KENNEL LICENSE

Certain animal facilities are required to obtain a license and be inspected by the Minnesota Board of Animal Health (BAH). As with all statutes, it's important to read the definition so as to know who it applies to:

Subd. 2. Kennel. "Kennel" means any place, building, tract of land, abode, or vehicle wherein or whereupon dogs or cats are kept, congregated, or confined, if the dogs or cats were obtained from municipalities, pounds, auctions, or by advertising for unwanted dogs or cats, or dogs or cats strayed, abandoned, or stolen. "Kennel" does not include a pound owned and operated by any political subdivision of the state or a person's home where dogs and cats are kept as pets.

Note the words above: "if the dogs or cats.....were strayed, abandoned or stolen." As dogs and cats within dog/cat breeding facilities are not strays and a breeder does not advertise for strays, commercial dog/cat breeding kennels do not fall under this definition and, therefore, are not licensed or inspected by the MN BAH.

Minnesota Statute 347.31: Kennels and Dealers

Explanation per MN Board of Animal Health

 


MINNESOTA DANGEROUS EXOTIC ANIMALS
On January 1, 2005, an ‘Exotic Animal Ownership’ law went into effect in Minnesota. With some exceptions, it prohibits individuals from “purchasing, obtaining, or owning certain exotic animals in Minnesota.” (per Minnesota Board of Animal Health website).    

 

 

OTHER MINNESOTA ANIMAL LAWS

There are other laws relating to animals in Minnesota. The Michigan State University College of Law has profiled these laws for each state. For details, go to:
http://www.animallaw.info/

Examples listed include:
MN - Dangerous - Minnesota Dangerous Dog Definitions, Dog Bites & Rabies Treatments
MN - Assistance Animals/Guide Dog Laws
MN - Dog - Consolidated Dog Laws
MN - Endangered Species Statute and Acquisition of Critical Natural Habitat
MN - Equine Activity Liability Statute
MN - Habitat - Minnesota Environmental Rights Act   
MN - Humane Slaughter - Slaughter of Livestock   
MN - Licenses - Unlicensed dogs
MN - Ordinances - Chanhassen and Minneapolis Animal Control Ordinances   
MN - Ordinances - Interpretation (dog ordinances) 
MN - Ordinances - Town Powers Listed; Formal Name
MN - Veterinary - Chapter 156. Veterinarians. Board of Veterinary Medicine.
MN - Ordinances - What electors may do at annual town meeting

 

 

©2011 Animal Folks Minnesota - Home - Contact    

 

 

 

"));